Ireland Calling
Ireland Calling Store

McAleese tells New York Times ‘Shame on you’ over J1 students story

Former Irish President Mary McAleese has slammed the New York Times for their coverage of the tragic deaths of the Irish students in California.

McAleese was appalled by the report and has written a strongly worded letter telling the paper “shame on you” and accusing them of using “lazy tabloid stereotypes”.

McAleese: 'Shame on you!' to New York Times over J1 students story

Six people were killed on Tuesday evening after a fourth floor balcony collapsed during celebrations at a 21st birthday party.

Five of the victims were young Irish students in America as part of the J1 work and study program.

Shockingly, the New York Times ran a story on their website the following day questioning the behaviour of Irish J1 students and accusing them of “being a source of embarrassment for Ireland”.

The story provoked an angry backlash from people in both Ireland and America who were stunned by the insensitivity of the paper.

The former President spent some time studying in America herself is the early 1970s, and considers the J1 Visa a fantastic opportunity for young Irish people.

She defended the students who died by pointing out that the New York Times had “rushed to judgement on their character without the remotest evidence”.

New York Times Public Editor Margaret Sullivan was asked about the report on television show Newstalk Breakfast. She said: “I think the New York Times made some pretty bad mistakes with this story and, yes, I think it was insensitive and not handled properly. I agree it was insensitive and that the complaints are very valid.

“I would like to explain quickly that as the public editor I don’t write or edit stories, I am an independent readers’ representative, so I can’t really speak for the paper and I’m speaking for myself.

Sign up to our FREE newsletters

Please click on your confirmation email,
Check your junk mail folder in case it gets sent there.

“It was explained to me that it was not the first day that the story went up online, it was kind of a second day approach story. I don’t think that was an excuse and I don’t think that it was appropriate but that’s the, I guess you could say, reason for it. You know, to go more deeply into another angle or to examine the visa programme.”

The New York Times has apologised if the report caused any offence but insisted they will not take it down.

5 thoughts on “McAleese tells New York Times ‘Shame on you’ over J1 students story

  1. Fred

    Hey Geraldine, the NY Times is anything but a liberal paper – they are owned by the infamous Koch brothers and are as conservative and insensitive as their owners

    25/06/2015 at 2:04 pm
  2. Geraldine Callaghan

    Sadly, the Irish are fair game for insensitive remarks, insults and stereotyping and No One is held accountable. If we of Irish decent went out and rioted, looted, and destroyed property we may get noticed and you can be assured we would be held accountable for our actions. We obviously don’t have a prosecutor that ” feels our pain and will seek justice” for us. The NY Times is a biased liberal rag. How insensitive can they be in light of this tragedy to young people and their families. May they find solace and peace.

    20/06/2015 at 10:30 am
  3. Rosemary Burns

    As an Irish American Iam ashamed at American paper, or any other paper would b so insensitive to the losing of 6 lives. Shame on you!!

    19/06/2015 at 5:43 pm
  4. Coreen

    The NY Times is nothing but a despicable rag. We grieve for your loss.

    19/06/2015 at 4:07 pm
  5. mazie

    shame on you go after the people who own the building shame on them who own the building they are resbondville and shoul be hale accountable

    shame on you go shame the people who own the building they are responsible for thes deaths

    18/06/2015 at 10:32 pm

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

XSLT Plugin by Leo Jiang